Mahaprasad Nanda

The demand for Citizenship by Investment (CBI) programs is increasing as High-Net-Worth Individuals (HNWIs) seek alternative citizenship and global mobility1. These programs offer a fast-track to citizenship in exchange for a significant financial contribution to the host country, providing benefits such as visa-free travel, tax advantages, and a secure future for families1. For Indian investors, navigating the legal framework, due diligence requirements, tax implications, and potential risks associated with CBI programs is crucial. This article serves as a comprehensive guide to these critical aspects.

Understanding Citizenship by Investment (CBI) Programs

CBI programs, also known as economic citizenship, allow individuals to obtain an additional citizenship or passport by making economic contributions to another country2. These programs are designed to attract foreign investment and stimulate economic growth1. They often aim to improve the welfare and economic development of the host country3. Typical investment options include real estate, business ventures, or government bonds1. In exchange, investors receive full citizenship, often with benefits such as visa-free travel, business opportunities, and potential tax savings1. CBI programs often have minimal to no residency requirements3. St. Kitts and Nevis launched the world's first CBI program in 1984, and it continues to this day4.

Countries with CBI Programs

Over 100 countries have some form of investment migration legislation5. Several countries offer CBI programs, with varying investment requirements and benefits. Some of the popular options include:

Legal Framework Governing CBI Programs in India

While CBI programs offer attractive opportunities, Indian investors must be aware of the legal framework governing such programs in India. The legal implications of holding dual citizenship for Indians are complex and require careful consideration.

The Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) of 1999 regulates foreign exchange transactions in India. Indian residents investing in CBI programs must comply with FEMA regulations, including obtaining necessary approvals from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) for outward remittances.

Furthermore, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) plays a significant role in regulating CBI programs internationally6. The FATF sets international standards to combat money laundering and terrorist financing, and countries with CBI programs are expected to comply with these standards.

In addition to these regulations, the Indian government is actively working to introduce legislation to combat illegal lending apps7. This demonstrates the government's commitment to regulating financial activities and protecting investors.

Due Diligence Requirements for Indian Investors

Due diligence is a critical aspect of CBI programs. It involves a series of investigative practices that identify and verify information about an investor8. This process is crucial to maintaining the integrity and transparency of CBI programs and protecting the host country and its international partners from illicit actors8. Due diligence plays a crucial role in mitigating risks, protecting investors, and maintaining the integrity of CBI programs8.

Due diligence reports provide a thorough background check on individuals, verifying vital information necessary for decision-making10. These checks include:

• Education credentials
• Company associations
• Personal details
• Employment records
• Track records
• Licenses, certificates & awards
• Potential conflicts of interest
• Political and criminal links

KYC and AML Compliance

Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) compliance are essential components of due diligence in CBI programs. These processes help verify the investor's identity, assess their risk level, prevent fraud, and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements11.

KYC procedures typically involve verifying the applicant's identity, address, and income12. AML compliance focuses on identifying and preventing money laundering activities, such as scrutinizing the applicant's financial records and ensuring they are not involved in any suspicious or unlawful activities13.

Advancements in technology, such as blockchain, have the potential to improve KYC/AML compliance in CBI programs14. Blockchain technology can be used to create shared, decentralized databases that help maintain up-to-date and accurate customer information while ensuring compliance with global regulations.

Tax Implications for Indian Investors

Investing in CBI programs can have significant tax implications for Indian investors. It is crucial to understand the tax laws of both India and the host country to avoid potential liabilities. CBI programs can have a complex impact on tax evasion, potentially decreasing individual detection probabilities and making it less likely that countries exchange tax information15.

Potential Tax Liabilities

Indian investors may be subject to tax liabilities in India on their global income, including income earned from investments made in CBI programs16. The tax residency status of the investor plays a crucial role in determining their tax obligations16.

Some CBI programs offer tax benefits, such as reduced tax rates or exemptions on certain types of income17. However, it is essential to carefully evaluate these benefits in light of the overall tax implications.

Here's a comparison of the tax systems in some popular CBI nations:

Potential Risks and Challenges

While CBI programs offer numerous advantages, Indian investors must be aware of the potential risks and challenges involved. CBI programs have faced increasing scrutiny and challenges, including scandals, legal disputes, and regulatory changes18.

Legal and Regulatory Risks

One of the primary risks is the potential for changes in the CBI program regulations or policies of the host country18. These changes could affect the investor's citizenship status or investment returns.

Financial Risks

The possibility of fraud or scams is another significant risk18. Investors must exercise caution and conduct thorough due diligence to avoid falling prey to fraudulent schemes.

Real estate financing in CBI programs also carries inherent risks20. If developers fail to deliver on real estate projects, the government may grant citizenship without receiving the intended economic benefits. This can lead to financial losses for both the government and investors.

Reputational and Ethical Considerations

CBI programs have faced scrutiny due to concerns about money laundering and security risks19. This negative perception can affect the reputation of both the host country and the investors.

Some critics argue that CBI programs commodify citizenship and create inequalities21. These ethical considerations are important for investors to consider when evaluating CBI programs.

Other Challenges

Other challenges faced by investors in CBI programs include:

• Off-taker risk: This refers to the risk that the primary off-takers of power, such as electricity distribution companies, may be unwilling or unable to pay for the power generated by renewable energy projects22.
• Currency risk: Financing renewable energy projects in India with foreign capital exposes investors to the risk of currency devaluation22.
• Risks associated with intermediaries: Intermediaries, such as marketing agents and service providers, play a significant role in CBI programs. However, their involvement can also introduce risks, such as potential conflicts of interest and lack of transparency23.

Reputable Advisors for CBI Programs

Given the complexities of CBI programs, seeking professional advice from reputable legal and financial advisors is crucial24. These advisors can provide guidance on legal compliance, due diligence, tax planning, and risk mitigation.

Some reputable firms that offer both legal and financial advisory services for CBI programs include:

• CS Global Partners: Specializes in CBI programs and government advisory24.
• Henley & Partners: Global leader in residence and citizenship by investment25.

Other legal advisors include:

• Rajendra Criminal Law Firm: Provides expert legal representation for individuals and organizations involved in CBI court cases26.
• Advocate Aashutosh Srivastava: Offers legal services for CBI and EOW cases27.

For financial advice, consider:

• VSRK Capital: Offers financial planning services in India28.

Conclusion

CBI programs offer a unique opportunity for Indian investors to acquire alternative citizenship and enhance their global mobility. However, it is essential to approach these programs with a thorough understanding of the legal framework, due diligence requirements, tax implications, and potential risks.

Indian investors should carefully consider the implications of potentially renouncing their Indian citizenship and ensure they comply with all relevant regulations, including FEMA. They should also conduct thorough due diligence to mitigate risks, such as fraud and changes in regulations. Seeking expert advice from reputable legal and financial advisors is highly recommended.

Furthermore, it is crucial to evaluate the tax implications of CBI programs, considering both the tax laws of India and the host country. While some programs offer tax benefits, it is essential to assess these benefits in light of potential liabilities.

By conducting proper due diligence, seeking expert advice, and carefully evaluating the options, Indian investors can make informed decisions and maximize the benefits of CBI programs while aligning their choices with their individual financial goals and risk tolerance.

Works cited

1. Citizenship by Investment Countries & Programs List in 2024 - Global Residence Index, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://globalresidenceindex.com/citizenship-by-investment/

2. www.imf.org, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Data/Statistics/BPM6/approved-guidance-notes/b8-recording-citizenbyinvestment-programs.ashx#:~:text=Citizenship%2Dby%2Dinvestment%20(CBI,aggregate%2C%20have%20a%20macroeconomic%20impact.

3. B.8 Recording Citizenship-by-Investment Programs - International Monetary Fund (IMF), accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/gfs/gfsac/pdf/GN_B8_GFS_Consultation.pdf

4. What is Citizenship by Investment - Holborn Pass, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://holbornpass.com/citizenship-by-investment/what-is-citizenship-by-investment/

5. List of countries that offer citizenship by investment visa - Wise, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://wise.com/gb/blog/citizenship-by-investment-visa-countries-list

6. Misuse of Citizenship and Residency by Investment Programmes - FATF, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.fatf-gafi.org/en/publications/Methodsandtrends/misuse-CBI-RBI-programmes.html

7. India's Government Plans Legislation To Combat Illegal Lending Apps | Crowdfund Insider, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2024/12/234399-indias-government-plans-legislation-to-combat-illegal-lending-apps/

8. Dominica Citizenship by Investment Program: Due Diligence, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.cbiu.gov.dm/news/agent-news/due-diligence-in-dominica-citizenship-by-investment/

9. Citizenship by Investment Due Diligence | CS Global Partners, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/news/citizenship-by-investment-due-diligence/

10. Citizenship by Investment (CBI) due diligence | LSEG, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.lseg.com/en/risk-intelligence/due-diligence-services/investment-migration

11. AML vs KYC: Differences, Compliance & Best Practices - Fenergo, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://resources.fenergo.com/blogs/kyc-aml

12. A KYC Guide to Financial Risk Assessment - AML Watcher, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://amlwatcher.com/blog/a-kyc-method-you-need-to-know-about/

13. The role of due diligence in the Citizenship by Investment application process, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/news/the-role-of-due-diligence-in-the-citizenship-by-investment-application-process/

14. Blockchain In The Citizenship By Investment Industry - Forbes, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinesscouncil/2023/11/17/blockchain-in-the-citizenship-by-investment-industry/

15. Escaping the Exchange of Information: Tax Evasion via Citizenship-by-Investment, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.uni-goettingen.de/de/document/download/7f8ca71dadaf70cd95378e2777550514.pdf/2021_07_CBI.pdf

16. Are there any tax implications associated with citizenship by investment? - JHMarlin, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://jhmarlin.com/are-there-any-tax-implications-associated-with-citizenship-by-investment/

17. Best Citizenship by Investment in 2024 - Harvey Law Group, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://harveylawcorporation.com/citizenship-by-investment/

18. A Surfeit of Scandals: The CBI Market's 6 Existential Risks - Investment Migration Insider, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.imidaily.com/opinion/a-surfeit-of-scandals-the-cbi-markets-6-existential-risks/

19. New Regulator to Reshape Caribbean CBI Industry for the Better - IMI, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.imidaily.com/opinion/new-regulator-to-reshape-caribbean-cbi-industry-for-the-better/

20. The Risks of CBI Real Estate "Financing" - IMI - Investment Migration Insider, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.imidaily.com/sponsored-feature/the-risks-of-cbi-real-estate-financing/

21. Avenues for EU action on citizenship and residence by investment schemes - European Parliament, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2021/694217/EPRS_STU(2021)694217_EN.pdf

22. Getting to India's Renewable Energy Targets: A Business Case for Institutional Investment - Climate Policy Initiative, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://climatepolicyinitiative.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Getting-to-Indias-Renewable-Energy-Targets-A-Business-Case-for-Institutional-Investment.pdf

23. Misuse of Citizenship and Residency by Investment Programmes - FATF, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.fatf-gafi.org/content/dam/fatf-gafi/reports/Misuse-CBI-RBI-Programmes.pdf.coredownload.pdf

24. CS Global | Citizenship by Investment Agents, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/

25. Henley & Partners: Residence and Citizenship by Investment, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/

26. CBI Court Cases Legal Services | Best Criminal Lawyers Chennai, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://criminaladvocate.in/cbi-court-cases-legal-services/

27. CBI and EOW Cases Lawyer - Advocate Aashutosh Srivastava, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://www.advocateaashutoshsrivastava.com/cbi-and-eow-cases-lawyer/

28. Best Financial Advisor in India 2024: A Comprehensive Guide - VSRK Capital, accessed on December 24, 2024, https://vsrkcapital.com/best-financial-planner-in-india/