Mahaprasad Nanda

Introduction

Citizenship by investment (CBI) programs, also known as "economic citizenship" programs, Citizenship by Investment (CBI) programs have become a popular way for high-net-worth individuals and their families to obtain citizenship in another country. These programs, sometimes referred to as "golden passports" or "cash-for-passport" programs, provide a variety of advantages, including visa-free travel, tax benefits, and increased global mobility.

As of mid-2023, more than twenty countries offered CBI programs, with more countries planning to launch similar programs in the near future. This increase in interest can be attributed to a number of factors, including globalization, political and economic instability in some areas, and the increase in remote work, which allows for more flexibility in living and working arrangements.

History of CBI Programs

The origins of CBI programs can be traced back to the 1980s. St. Kitts and Nevis introduced the first Citizenship by Investment (CBI) program in 1984 to encourage foreign investment and boost the island's economy 5 2. The success of this program led other Caribbean nations like Dominica, Grenada, and St. Lucia to establish their own CBI programs 6. In the 1990s, CBI programs expanded beyond the Caribbean, with countries like Canada and the United States launching Immigrant Investor Programs (IIPs), offering a pathway to permanent residency and eventual citizenship through investment .

The demand for CBI programs has steadily increased due to factors such as globalization, political instability, and the desire for greater personal and financial security . The COVID-19 pandemic intensified this trend as wealthy individuals sought alternative citizenship and safe havens for themselves and their families .

Economic Impacts of CBI Programs

• Positive Impacts:
  • Finances infrastructure development, social welfare initiatives, and economic growth.
  • Rebuilt homes, schools, and hospitals in Dominica after Hurricane Maria.
  • Diversified the economy and reduced dependence on the sugar industry in St. Kitts and Nevis.
  • Contributed to 13% of direct investment inflows in Portugal in 2014.
• Negative Impacts:
  • Fosters overreliance on foreign investment, leading to economic volatility and instability.
  • Inflates real estate prices, making housing less affordable for local residents.
  • Exacerbates income inequality.
  • Raises concerns about financial integrity and regulatory oversight due to potential for tax evasion and money laundering.

Social and Cultural Impact of CBI Programs

The social and cultural implications of CBI programs are complex and multifaceted. The influx of foreign investors can introduce new ideas, skills, and cultural diversity to the host country. However, it can also create social tensions, particularly if there is a perception that wealthy foreigners receive preferential treatment or displace local residents.

Furthermore, CBI programs raise fundamental questions about national identity and the meaning of citizenship. Critics contend that these programs commodify citizenship, reducing it to a mere transaction, and eroding the traditional concept of belonging to a nation based on shared values, history, and culture. There are also concerns that CBI programs can lead to a two-tiered citizenship system, where wealthy foreigners enjoy more rights and privileges than native-born citizens.

Ethical and Legal Concerns Associated with CBI Programs

Citizenship by Investment (CBI) programs raise ethical and legal concerns. They can be exploited by criminals for money laundering and tax evasion, and pose national security risks due to inadequate vetting. Additionally, commodifying citizenship may undermine civic values.

• Potential for Exploitation: Criminals and corrupt officials may exploit CBI programs for money laundering, tax evasion, and escaping justice due to a lack of transparency and due diligence.
• National Security Risks: Granting citizenship without thorough vetting can pose risks if individuals have connections to terrorist organizations or criminal networks.
• Commodification of Citizenship: CBI programs raise ethical questions about the commodification of citizenship and the potential erosion of national identity.

The Application Process for CBI Programs

The application process for Citizenship by Investment (CBI) programs generally involves several key steps, although specific requirements and procedures can vary significantly depending on the jurisdiction:

1. Eligibility Check:
   • This initial stage requires applicants to meet certain fundamental criteria to qualify for the program.
   • These criteria commonly include age restrictions, a clean criminal record, and proof of funds that have been obtained through legal means.
   • Additional requirements may exist depending on the specific program and country.
2. Documentation:
   • Applicants are required to compile and submit a comprehensive set of documents to support their application.
   • This typically includes personal identification documents (such as passports and birth certificates), financial records demonstrating the source and sufficiency of funds, and police clearance certificates to confirm the absence of a criminal record.
   • The specific documents required can vary depending on the program and the individual circumstances of the applicant.
3. Due Diligence:
   • A critical component of the CBI process is the thorough background checks conducted on applicants.
   • These checks are performed by government authorities and specialized agencies to verify the identity of applicants, scrutinize the source of their funds, and assess any potential criminal or security risks they may pose.
   • This step is essential to maintain the integrity of the CBI program and safeguard national security.
4. Investment:
   • The core of the CBI program lies in the investment that applicants are required to make.
   • This investment can take various forms depending on the program and the country, but commonly includes:
     • A contribution to a government fund designated for specific purposes such as economic development or infrastructure projects.
     • The purchase of real estate that meets certain criteria, such as minimum value or location requirements.
     • Investment in a local business venture that creates jobs and contributes to the economy.
5. Approval:
   • After the investment is made and all other requirements are met, the government reviews the application and conducts further due diligence if necessary.
   • If the application is approved, the applicant is granted citizenship in the country.
6. Citizenship and Passport:
   • Upon approval, applicants receive official citizenship certificates and passports.
   • These documents confer the rights and privileges of citizenship, including the ability to live, work, and travel freely within the country and potentially access visa-free travel to other countries.

Throughout this process, authorized agents often play a crucial role in assisting applicants. They provide guidance on program requirements, help with document preparation, and liaise with government authorities on behalf of their clients. Their expertise and support can be invaluable in navigating the complex and often time-consuming CBI application process.

Case Studies of Individuals Who Have Obtained Citizenship Through Investment Programs

The allure of Citizenship by Investment (CBI) programs has been highlighted by several notable cases where individuals have leveraged these programs to their advantage. One prominent example is Roman Abramovich, a Russian billionaire who faced obstacles in renewing his British visa. In 2018, Abramovich successfully obtained Israeli citizenship, demonstrating how CBI programs can provide a pathway to citizenship in a new country when faced with difficulties in maintaining residency status elsewhere.

Another notable case is that of Mehul Choksi, an Indian businessman who was embroiled in fraud charges in India. In 2017, Choksi acquired citizenship in Antigua and Barbuda through the country's CBI program. This case underscored the potential for CBI programs to be utilized by individuals seeking to evade legal proceedings in their home country by acquiring citizenship and subsequently residing in a jurisdiction with potentially less stringent extradition treaties or legal cooperation agreements.

These instances shed light on the broader implications of CBI programs and raise concerns about their potential for misuse. While these programs can offer legitimate benefits, such as attracting foreign investment and stimulating economic growth, they also raise questions about due diligence, transparency, and the potential for exploitation by individuals seeking to circumvent legal obligations or gain access to favorable tax regimes.

The cases of Abramovich and Choksi highlight the need for robust safeguards and thorough vetting processes within CBI programs to prevent their misuse. Striking a balance between facilitating legitimate investment and safeguarding against potential abuse remains a crucial challenge for countries offering CBI programs.

Expert Opinions and Analysis on the Future of CBI Programs

• Demand for CBI programs is expected to grow due to globalization, political instability, increased mobility of wealthy individuals, and the rise of remote work.
• Increased scrutiny and regulation of CBI programs is also predicted due to concerns about money laundering, tax evasion, and national security.
• The future of CBI programs will be shaped by global economic and political landscape, regulatory frameworks, and the evolving needs and preferences of high-net-worth individuals.
• Innovative approaches are being explored by some countries, such as offering citizenship in exchange for investments in sustainable development or social impact initiatives.

Conclusion

Citizenship by investment programs offer opportunities for economic growth, global mobility, and tax benefits, but also raise ethical, legal, and socio-cultural concerns. The future of these programs depends on economic, political, and social factors, and requires transparent, accountable, and sustainable implementation by governments and international organizations.

Please find the summery table to understand the CBI of each country by clicking on the link

Citations & Source of research

1. The Evolution of Citizenship by Investment Programs - Kiplinger, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.kiplinger.com/kiplinger-advisor-collective/evolution-of-citizenship-by-investment-programs

2. Immigrant investor programs - Wikipedia, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigrant_investor_programs

3. The 13 Planned Citizenship by Investment Programs The Market is Waiting For: Which Will Open First? - IMI, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.imidaily.com/analysis/the-13-planned-citizenship-by-investment-programs-the-market-is-waiting-for-which-will-open-first/

4. Full article: Do passports pay off? Assessing the economic outcomes of citizenship by investment programs - Taylor & Francis Online, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1369183X.2024.2332825

5. en.wikipedia.org, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigrant_investor_programs#:~:text=St%20Kitts%20and%20Nevis%20was,an%20approved%20real%20estate%20development.

6. The Ultimate Citizenship by Investment Guide | CS Global Partners Limited, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/resources/your-ultimate-citizenship-by-investment-guide/

7. History | GIIC - Global Investor Immigration Council, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.giic.uk/investor-immigration/history/

8. Citizenship by Investment Countries & Programs List in 2024 - Global Residence Index, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://globalresidenceindex.com/citizenship-by-investment/

9. Citizenship by Investment: Transactions of National Identity - Harvard International Review, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://hir.harvard.edu/citizenship-by-investment/

10. B.8 Recording Citizenship-by-Investment Programs - International Monetary Fund (IMF), accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Data/Statistics/BPM6/approved-guidance-notes/b8-recording-citizenbyinvestment-programs.ashx

11. The Pros and Cons of Using Investment to Obtain Citizenship or Residency | Citizen Lane, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.citizen-lane.com/blog/the-pros-and-cons-of-using-investment-to-obtain-citizenship-or-residency

12. B.8 Recording Citizenship-by-Investment Programs - International Monetary Fund (IMF), accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/gfs/gfsac/pdf/GN_B8_GFS_Consultation.pdf

13. Chapter 7. Managing Economic Citizenship Program Inflows: Reducing Risk and Maximizing Benefits in: Unleashing Growth and Strengthening Resilience in the Caribbean - IMF eLibrary, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/book/9781484315194/ch07.xml

14. Golden Passports and Visas: How Investment Migration Works, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/golden-passports-and-visas-how-investment-migration-works

15. Investor Citizenship Schemes - European Commission, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/policies/justice-and-fundamental-rights/eu-citizenship-and-democracy/eu-citizenship/investor-citizenship-schemes_en

16. Misuse of Citizenship and Residency by Investment Programmes - FATF, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.fatf-gafi.org/en/publications/Methodsandtrends/misuse-CBI-RBI-programmes.html

17. Navigating the Complexities of Citizenship by Investment Due Diligence, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://investmentmigration.org/articles/navigating-the-complexities-of-citizenship-by-investment-due-diligence/

18. Citizenship by investment: is it really so bad? | by Marco Mazzeschi - Medium, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://mm-63015.medium.com/citizenship-by-investment-is-it-really-so-bad-e1c549c947a

19. Antigua and Barbuda Investment Citizenship with Crypto - Harvey Law Group, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://harveylawcorporation.com/antigua-and-barbuda-citizenship-by-investment/

20. Austrian Citizenship by Exceptional Achievement - CS Global Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/austrian-citizenship-by-investment-program-benefits-requirements-and-investment-options/

21. Dominica Citizenship by Investment Program 2021, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.dominicacitizenshipbyinvestment.com/

22. Citizenship by Investment: Legal Implications and Trends - CaseFox, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.casefox.com/blog/citizenship-by-investment-legal-implications-and-trends/

23. Faq - Dominica Citizenship by Investment, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.cbiu.gov.dm/faqs/

24. Best Citizenship by Investment in 2024 - Harvey Law Group, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://harveylawcorporation.com/citizenship-by-investment/

25. www.henleyglobal.com, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment

26. Antigua and Barbuda Citizenship by Investment Program 2025, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/citizenship-antigua-and-barbuda-en/

27. Pros & cons of Dominica second citizenship - Caribbean passports, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/dominica-passport-benefits/

28. Antigua Barbuda Citizenship by Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/antigua-barbuda

29. Process Timeline Antigua and Barbuda Citizenship by Investment, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.gisgl.com/citizenship/countries/antigua-and-barbuda/how-it-works

30. Antigua and Barbuda passport benefits and drawbacks for an investor, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/antigua-and-barbuda-citizenship-benefits/

31. Citizenship by investment in Austria | Passports.IO, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://passports.io/citizenship/austria/donation/at1

32. Austria - Citizenship by Investment | Citizen Lane, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.citizen-lane.com/austria-citizenship-by-investment

33. Austria Golden Visa: Requirements & How to Get One | iVisa, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://ivisatravel.com/austria/c/austria-golden-visa

34. Austria Citizenship by Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/austria

35. Dominica Citizenship: Expert Legal Pathway for Your Future - Harvey Law Group, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://harveylawcorporation.com/dominica-citizenship-by-investment/

36. Dominica Citizenship by Investment Program 2025 - Caribbean passports, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/citizenship-dominica-en/

37. Citizenship by investment in Dominica | Passports.IO, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://passports.io/citizenship/dominica/donation/dm1

38. The Egyptian Citizenship by Investment Program - Andersen in Egypt, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://eg.andersen.com/egyptian-citizenship-investment/

39. Egypt Citizenship by Investment Program - IMI - Investment Migration Insider, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.imidaily.com/egypt-citizenship-by-investment-program/

40. A Guide to Egyptian Residency & Citizenship - CS Global Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/citizenship-investment/egypt/

41. Egypt Citizenship by Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/egypt

42. How to Obtain Egyptian Citizenship by Investment in 2023 - APEX Capital Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://apexcapital.partners/egyptian-citizenship/

43. Grenada Citizenship by Investment - Davies & Associates, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.usimmigrationadvisor.com/grenada-citizenship-by-investment-programme.html

44. Grenada Citizenship by Investment - RIF Trust, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.riftrust.com/citizenship-by-investment/grenada/

45. Grenada's Citizenship by Investment - NTL Trust, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://ntltrust.com/citizenship-by-investment/grenada/

46. Grenada Citizenship by Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/grenada

47. www.endevio.com, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.endevio.com/en/insights/malta-citizenship-by-investment-programme#:~:text=Malta%20Citizenship%20by%20Investment%20Cost&text=After%20three%20(3)%20years%20of,member%20included%20in%20the%20application).

48. How long does it take to get the Malta citizenship by investment?, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://malta-citizenship.info/citizenship/articles/how-long-does-it-take-to-get-malta-citizenship-by-investment.php

49. Malta Citizenship by Naturalization - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/malta

50. Malta Citizenship by Investment | Chetcuti Cauchi Advocates Malta Law Firm, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.ccmalta.com/publications/malta-citizenship-investment

51. Montenegro Citizenship by Investment Program - Guide Consultants, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.guideconsultants.com/citizenship-by-investment/montenegro-citizenship/

52. Montenegro - Citizenship by Investment Program - Passports.IO, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://passports.io/citizenship/montenegro/donation/me1

53. Montenegro Citizenship-By-Investment Program | Citizen Lane, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.citizen-lane.com/montenegro-citizenship-by-investment-program

54. Montenegrin Citizenship by Investment - Montenegro Guides, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://montenegroguides.co/citizenship-passports/by-investment/

55. North Macedonia Citizenship By Investment, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.ketencilaw.com/north-macedonia-citizenship-by-investment.html

56. North Macedonia Citizenship Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/north-macedonia

57. North Macedonia Citizenship by Investment | Citizenship Invest | New Life, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.citizenshipinvest.com/en/programs/north-macedonia-citizenship/

58. St. Kitts Citizenship by Investment - Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/st-kitts-nevis

59. St. Kitts and Nevis Citizenship by Investment | J.H. Marlin, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://jhmarlin.com/st-kitts-and-nevis-citizenship-by-investment/

60. Benefits of St. Kitts and Nevis Citizenship | Grant Thornton, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.grantthornton.kn/service/cip/benefits-of-st.-kitts-and-nevis-citizenship

61. 15 key benefits of St Kitts and Nevis citizenship by investment in 2025, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/st-kitts-passport-benefits/

62. St Kitts and Nevis Citizenship by Investment - Arton Capital, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.artoncapital.com/global-citizen-programs/st-kitts-nevis/

63. St Lucia's citizenship by investment program: Ultimate guide - Caribbean passports, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/st-lucia-citizenship-by-investment/

64. St Lucia Citizenship Programme - Holborn Pass, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://holbornpass.com/st-lucia-citizenship-programme/

65. St. Lucia Citizenship by Investment | Henley & Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.henleyglobal.com/citizenship-investment/st-lucia

66. Turkey Citizenship by Investment and Passport Guide | Global Residence Index, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://globalresidenceindex.com/turkey-citizenship-investment/

67. TURKISH CITIZENSHIP AMOUNT RAISED TO 400 THOUSAND USD – RESIDENCE TURKEY, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://residencepermitturkey.com/turkish-citizenship-new-increase

68. Turkish Citizenship & Residency By Investment And Qualifying For The US E2 Visa, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://www.usimmigrationadvisor.com/turkey-citizenship-by-investment-programme.html

69. Turkish dual citizenship – everything you need to know - CS Global Partners, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://csglobalpartners.com/news-turkish-dual-citizenship-everything-you-need-to-know-2/

70. Pros and Cons of Turkish Citizenship by Investment - TheHamptons.gr - Hamptons Greece, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://thehamptons.gr/pros-and-cons-of-turkish-citizenship-by-investment/

71. Vanuatu Citizenship by Investment — Benefits, Costs and Requirements in 2025, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/vanuatu-citizenship-by-investment/

72. Vanuatu Citizenship by Investment Programme | Holborn Pass, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://holbornpass.com/country-programme/vanuatu/

73. 9 key benefits of Vanuatu citizenship in 2025 - Caribbean passports, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://imin-caribbean.com/blog/vanuatu-citizenship-benefits/

74. Citizenship by investment in Vanuatu | Passports.IO, accessed on December 23, 2024, https://passports.io/citizenship/vanuatu/donation/vu1