Consultants, freelancers, and contractors don't have traditional employer-employee relationships. Here's how to navigate H-1B, O-1, and green card options when you work for multiple clients or yourself.
1 min read
1 min read
Consultants and contractors can pursue U.S. work authorization through several paths: O-1 with agent petitioner (most flexible for multi-client work), H-1B through staffing agency or end client, or self-petitioned green cards (EB-1A, EB-2 NIW).
The key challenge is establishing the required "employer-employee relationship" for H-1B or finding an agent to petition for O-1. Self-petitioned green cards are often the best long-term solution since they don't require employer sponsorship.
Traditional H-1B requires employer-employee relationship
Independent contractors struggle because USCIS scrutinizes control and supervision.
O-1 with agent is ideal for consultants
Agents can petition for O-1, allowing you to work for multiple clients.
Staffing agencies can sponsor H-1B
But third-party placement arrangements face heightened scrutiny.
Self-petitioned green cards are best long-term
EB-1A and EB-2 NIW don't require employer sponsorship.
Documentation is critical
Contracts, client agreements, and work arrangements must be carefully documented.
B-1 in lieu of H-1B is limited
Only works for short-term, specific situations.
Traditional H-1B requires employer-employee relationship
Independent contractors struggle because USCIS scrutinizes control and supervision.
O-1 with agent is ideal for consultants
Agents can petition for O-1, allowing you to work for multiple clients.
Staffing agencies can sponsor H-1B
But third-party placement arrangements face heightened scrutiny.
Self-petitioned green cards are best long-term
EB-1A and EB-2 NIW don't require employer sponsorship.
Documentation is critical
Contracts, client agreements, and work arrangements must be carefully documented.
B-1 in lieu of H-1B is limited
Only works for short-term, specific situations.
Why traditional H-1B is difficult:
USCIS requires an "employer-employee relationship" where the employer has the right to control:
When and where work is performed
What work is performed
How work is performed
Hiring and firing authority
Independent contractors typically:
Set their own hours
Work for multiple clients
Control their own methods
Invoice clients rather than receive W-2
Result: USCIS may deny H-1B if relationship looks like independent contracting rather than employment.
What it is: O-1 allows an "agent" to petition on behalf of the beneficiary, enabling work for multiple clients.
How it works:
Agent (typically an agency or attorney acting as agent) files O-1 petition
Petition lists multiple clients/engagements you'll work for
You work for various clients under single O-1
Agent handles visa compliance and reporting
Who can be an agent:
Immigration attorneys who act as agents
Talent agencies (entertainment industry)
Specialized O-1 agent services
Professional employer organizations (PEOs)
Requirements:
Meet O-1 extraordinary ability criteria (3 of 8)
Have contracts or engagement letters from clients
Agent agreement in place
Advantages:
Work for multiple clients simultaneously
No single employer dependency
Flexibility to add/change clients
Ideal for consulting model
Costs:
O-1 filing fees: $1,655
Premium processing: $2,805
Attorney/agent fees: $5,000-$15,000
Agent ongoing fees: $500-$2,000/year (varies)
Evidence required:
Contracts or letters from intended clients
Itinerary of engagements (can be tentative)
O-1 evidence (publications, awards, press, etc.)
What it is: Staffing company employs you (W-2) and places you at client sites.
How it works:
Staffing agency is your legal employer
Agency sponsors H-1B
You work at client locations
Agency pays you, handles taxes, provides benefits
USCIS scrutiny:
Third-party placement arrangements are heavily scrutinized
Agency must demonstrate it maintains employer-employee relationship
Client site work arrangements must be documented
Shorter approval periods may be granted (1-year increments vs 3 years)
What agencies must show:
Right to control your work
Authority to hire/fire
Pay and benefits structure
Supervision mechanisms
Specific client contracts
Challenges:
Higher RFE rates for third-party placements
May get 1-year approvals instead of 3 years
Agency takes significant cut of billing rate
Less stable than direct employment
When this works:
You work primarily for one or two clients
Staffing agency has strong H-1B track record
Client relationship is long-term
What it is: Your primary client sponsors H-1B directly, even though you're a "consultant."
How it works:
Client treats you as employee for visa purposes
You may still bill as consultant but are W-2 for the client
Client files H-1B petition
Requirements:
Client must be willing to sponsor
Must convert to W-2 employee (not 1099 contractor)
Full-time or part-time employment (not project-based)
Challenges:
Clients often don't want to sponsor contractors
You lose flexibility to work for other clients
Must commit to single employer
When this works:
You have one primary client willing to sponsor
You're willing to convert from contractor to employee
Long-term engagement is expected
Why this is often best for consultants:
No employer required (self-petition)
No employer-employee relationship issues
Once approved, you can work for anyone (or yourself)
Eliminates visa dependency entirely
EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability):
Meet 3 of 10 criteria
Self-petition (no sponsor needed)
No backlog (even for Indians)
Best if you have strong evidence
EB-2 NIW (National Interest Waiver):
Work has substantial merit and national importance
Self-petition
Backlog for India (10+ years), but locks in priority date
Strategy for consultants:
Build evidence through consulting work (publications, speaking, impact)
File self-petition
Maintain whatever status you have while processing
Once green card approved, full freedom
What it is: Business visitor visa for short-term work where you're paid by foreign employer.
Strict requirements:
You must be employed and paid by foreign entity
Work in U.S. is incidental to foreign employment
No U.S. source income
Short-term, temporary assignment
Who this works for:
Foreign companies sending employees to U.S. briefly
Consultants employed by overseas firm with U.S. client
Who this doesn't work for:
U.S.-based consultants
Anyone paid by U.S. clients
Long-term arrangements
Limitations:
Very narrow application
USCIS and CBP scrutinize heavily
Not suitable for most consultants
For O-1 with Agent:
Agent agreement
Client contracts or engagement letters
Itinerary of work (can be tentative)
Evidence of O-1 criteria
Description of services to be performed
For H-1B Through Staffing Agency:
Employment contract with agency
Master service agreement with end client
Statement of work for each engagement
Evidence of agency's control and supervision
Client site work details
For Self-Petitioned Green Card:
Evidence of extraordinary ability or national interest
Documentation of your work and impact
Recommendation letters (can be from clients)
No employer documentation required
Consultants have unique evidence opportunities:
Client Testimonials:
Get letters from clients describing your impact
Document projects and outcomes
Quantify results (revenue generated, problems solved)
Industry Recognition:
Speaking at conferences about your expertise
Writing articles about your specialty
Awards for consulting work
Original Contributions:
Methodologies you've developed
Tools or frameworks you've created
Case studies of your impact
High Compensation:
Consulting rates are often high
Document billing rates and income
Compare to industry standards
Phase 1: Establish U.S. Presence
O-1 with agent (work for multiple clients)
OR H-1B through staffing agency/client
Phase 2: Build Evidence
Continue consulting while building extraordinary ability evidence
Publications, speaking, awards, client impact
Phase 3: File Self-Petition
EB-1A or EB-2 NIW
No employer sponsorship needed
Process while maintaining O-1 or H-1B
Phase 4: Green Card
Once approved, work for anyone (or yourself)
No more visa constraints
Full consulting freedom
Mistake 1: Trying to Get H-1B as Independent Contractor
USCIS will deny H-1B if you're truly independent contractor with no employer control.
Fix: Convert to W-2 employment or use O-1 with agent.
Mistake 2: Not Documenting Client Relationships
You have great clients but no formal contracts or documentation.
Fix: Get written contracts, engagement letters, and testimonials for every client.
Mistake 3: Ignoring Self-Petition Options
Consultants focus on work visas and don't realize they may qualify for self-petitioned green cards.
Fix: Evaluate EB-1A and NIW eligibility based on your consulting track record.
Mistake 4: Using B-1 Incorrectly
Consultants try to use B-1 for work that requires H-1B.
Fix: B-1 is only for narrow circumstances. Most U.S. consulting work requires H-1B or O-1.
Work Arrangement Analysis
OpenSphere evaluates your consulting structure and identifies which visa options are viable.
Agent Identification
OpenSphere can recommend O-1 agents experienced with consultant petitions.
Evidence Mapping for Consultants
OpenSphere shows how to translate consulting work into O-1/EB-1A evidence: client impact, methodologies, industry recognition.
Self-Petition Evaluation
Based on your consulting track record, OpenSphere assesses EB-1A and NIW eligibility.
Option | Employer Required? | Multiple Clients? | Best For |
O-1 with Agent | Agent only | Yes | High-achieving consultants |
H-1B (Staffing) | Staffing agency | Limited | Consultants willing to be W-2 |
H-1B (Client) | End client | No | Primary client willing to sponsor |
EB-1A | No (self-petition) | Yes (after approval) | Strong evidence, want green card |
EB-2 NIW | No (self-petition) | Yes (after approval) | National importance work |
B-1 | Foreign employer | N/A | Very limited, short-term only |
Working as a consultant and unsure which visa path fits your work arrangement? Want to know if you qualify for O-1 or self-petitioned green card?
Take the OpenSphere evaluation. You'll get consultant-specific visa recommendations.
Explore Consultant Visa Options
Why traditional H-1B is difficult:
USCIS requires an "employer-employee relationship" where the employer has the right to control:
When and where work is performed
What work is performed
How work is performed
Hiring and firing authority
Independent contractors typically:
Set their own hours
Work for multiple clients
Control their own methods
Invoice clients rather than receive W-2
Result: USCIS may deny H-1B if relationship looks like independent contracting rather than employment.
What it is: O-1 allows an "agent" to petition on behalf of the beneficiary, enabling work for multiple clients.
How it works:
Agent (typically an agency or attorney acting as agent) files O-1 petition
Petition lists multiple clients/engagements you'll work for
You work for various clients under single O-1
Agent handles visa compliance and reporting
Who can be an agent:
Immigration attorneys who act as agents
Talent agencies (entertainment industry)
Specialized O-1 agent services
Professional employer organizations (PEOs)
Requirements:
Meet O-1 extraordinary ability criteria (3 of 8)
Have contracts or engagement letters from clients
Agent agreement in place
Advantages:
Work for multiple clients simultaneously
No single employer dependency
Flexibility to add/change clients
Ideal for consulting model
Costs:
O-1 filing fees: $1,655
Premium processing: $2,805
Attorney/agent fees: $5,000-$15,000
Agent ongoing fees: $500-$2,000/year (varies)
Evidence required:
Contracts or letters from intended clients
Itinerary of engagements (can be tentative)
O-1 evidence (publications, awards, press, etc.)
What it is: Staffing company employs you (W-2) and places you at client sites.
How it works:
Staffing agency is your legal employer
Agency sponsors H-1B
You work at client locations
Agency pays you, handles taxes, provides benefits
USCIS scrutiny:
Third-party placement arrangements are heavily scrutinized
Agency must demonstrate it maintains employer-employee relationship
Client site work arrangements must be documented
Shorter approval periods may be granted (1-year increments vs 3 years)
What agencies must show:
Right to control your work
Authority to hire/fire
Pay and benefits structure
Supervision mechanisms
Specific client contracts
Challenges:
Higher RFE rates for third-party placements
May get 1-year approvals instead of 3 years
Agency takes significant cut of billing rate
Less stable than direct employment
When this works:
You work primarily for one or two clients
Staffing agency has strong H-1B track record
Client relationship is long-term
What it is: Your primary client sponsors H-1B directly, even though you're a "consultant."
How it works:
Client treats you as employee for visa purposes
You may still bill as consultant but are W-2 for the client
Client files H-1B petition
Requirements:
Client must be willing to sponsor
Must convert to W-2 employee (not 1099 contractor)
Full-time or part-time employment (not project-based)
Challenges:
Clients often don't want to sponsor contractors
You lose flexibility to work for other clients
Must commit to single employer
When this works:
You have one primary client willing to sponsor
You're willing to convert from contractor to employee
Long-term engagement is expected
Why this is often best for consultants:
No employer required (self-petition)
No employer-employee relationship issues
Once approved, you can work for anyone (or yourself)
Eliminates visa dependency entirely
EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability):
Meet 3 of 10 criteria
Self-petition (no sponsor needed)
No backlog (even for Indians)
Best if you have strong evidence
EB-2 NIW (National Interest Waiver):
Work has substantial merit and national importance
Self-petition
Backlog for India (10+ years), but locks in priority date
Strategy for consultants:
Build evidence through consulting work (publications, speaking, impact)
File self-petition
Maintain whatever status you have while processing
Once green card approved, full freedom
What it is: Business visitor visa for short-term work where you're paid by foreign employer.
Strict requirements:
You must be employed and paid by foreign entity
Work in U.S. is incidental to foreign employment
No U.S. source income
Short-term, temporary assignment
Who this works for:
Foreign companies sending employees to U.S. briefly
Consultants employed by overseas firm with U.S. client
Who this doesn't work for:
U.S.-based consultants
Anyone paid by U.S. clients
Long-term arrangements
Limitations:
Very narrow application
USCIS and CBP scrutinize heavily
Not suitable for most consultants
For O-1 with Agent:
Agent agreement
Client contracts or engagement letters
Itinerary of work (can be tentative)
Evidence of O-1 criteria
Description of services to be performed
For H-1B Through Staffing Agency:
Employment contract with agency
Master service agreement with end client
Statement of work for each engagement
Evidence of agency's control and supervision
Client site work details
For Self-Petitioned Green Card:
Evidence of extraordinary ability or national interest
Documentation of your work and impact
Recommendation letters (can be from clients)
No employer documentation required
Consultants have unique evidence opportunities:
Client Testimonials:
Get letters from clients describing your impact
Document projects and outcomes
Quantify results (revenue generated, problems solved)
Industry Recognition:
Speaking at conferences about your expertise
Writing articles about your specialty
Awards for consulting work
Original Contributions:
Methodologies you've developed
Tools or frameworks you've created
Case studies of your impact
High Compensation:
Consulting rates are often high
Document billing rates and income
Compare to industry standards
Phase 1: Establish U.S. Presence
O-1 with agent (work for multiple clients)
OR H-1B through staffing agency/client
Phase 2: Build Evidence
Continue consulting while building extraordinary ability evidence
Publications, speaking, awards, client impact
Phase 3: File Self-Petition
EB-1A or EB-2 NIW
No employer sponsorship needed
Process while maintaining O-1 or H-1B
Phase 4: Green Card
Once approved, work for anyone (or yourself)
No more visa constraints
Full consulting freedom
Mistake 1: Trying to Get H-1B as Independent Contractor
USCIS will deny H-1B if you're truly independent contractor with no employer control.
Fix: Convert to W-2 employment or use O-1 with agent.
Mistake 2: Not Documenting Client Relationships
You have great clients but no formal contracts or documentation.
Fix: Get written contracts, engagement letters, and testimonials for every client.
Mistake 3: Ignoring Self-Petition Options
Consultants focus on work visas and don't realize they may qualify for self-petitioned green cards.
Fix: Evaluate EB-1A and NIW eligibility based on your consulting track record.
Mistake 4: Using B-1 Incorrectly
Consultants try to use B-1 for work that requires H-1B.
Fix: B-1 is only for narrow circumstances. Most U.S. consulting work requires H-1B or O-1.
Work Arrangement Analysis
OpenSphere evaluates your consulting structure and identifies which visa options are viable.
Agent Identification
OpenSphere can recommend O-1 agents experienced with consultant petitions.
Evidence Mapping for Consultants
OpenSphere shows how to translate consulting work into O-1/EB-1A evidence: client impact, methodologies, industry recognition.
Self-Petition Evaluation
Based on your consulting track record, OpenSphere assesses EB-1A and NIW eligibility.
Option | Employer Required? | Multiple Clients? | Best For |
O-1 with Agent | Agent only | Yes | High-achieving consultants |
H-1B (Staffing) | Staffing agency | Limited | Consultants willing to be W-2 |
H-1B (Client) | End client | No | Primary client willing to sponsor |
EB-1A | No (self-petition) | Yes (after approval) | Strong evidence, want green card |
EB-2 NIW | No (self-petition) | Yes (after approval) | National importance work |
B-1 | Foreign employer | N/A | Very limited, short-term only |
Working as a consultant and unsure which visa path fits your work arrangement? Want to know if you qualify for O-1 or self-petitioned green card?
Take the OpenSphere evaluation. You'll get consultant-specific visa recommendations.
Explore Consultant Visa Options
1. Can I work as a 1099 contractor on H-1B?
No. H-1B requires W-2 employer-employee relationship. You must be employed, not contracted.
2. What's the difference between O-1 agent and O-1 employer?
Employer is company you work for directly. Agent is third party who petitions on your behalf, allowing work for multiple clients.
3. How do I find an O-1 agent?
Immigration attorneys often act as agents. Some specialize in O-1 agent petitions. Ask for referrals from other consultants.
4. Can my LLC sponsor my own H-1B?
Very difficult. USCIS scrutinizes self-employment arrangements. You'd need to show LLC has sufficient control and is legitimate business separate from you.
5. What if I have one main client and several small clients?
Consider: Main client sponsors H-1B (become their W-2 employee), or use O-1 with agent to maintain multiple clients.
6. Do consulting fees count as "high salary" for O-1?
Yes, if documented properly. Show billing rates, income, and comparison to industry standards.
7. Can I switch from consulting to full-time employment?
Yes. If you have O-1, new employer can file O-1 transfer. If you have H-1B, new employer files H-1B transfer.
8. What evidence do consultants typically have for O-1?
Client testimonials (critical role), industry speaking/writing (authorship), high billing rates (high remuneration), awards, and original methodologies.
9. Is it harder for consultants to get visas?
More complex due to employer-employee issues, but definitely possible. O-1 with agent is designed for this situation.
10. Can I start my own consulting company on green card?
Yes. Once you have green card (through any path), you can work for any employer including your own company.
Explore Topics
0%
Explore Topics
0%
