Self-petitioned green cards (EB-1A, NIW) cost $15,000-$30,000 out of pocket but can save Indians 10-15 years of waiting. Here's how to calculate whether the investment makes sense for you.
1 min read
1 min read
For most Indians and Chinese on employer-sponsored tracks, self-petitioned green cards offer massive ROI. EB-1A costs ~$20,000-$30,000 but has no backlog, meaning green card in 2-3 years vs 10-15+ years for employer-sponsored EB-2.
The value: 10+ years of career freedom, no employer dependency, ability to start companies, negotiate freely, and change jobs without visa concerns. For non-backlog countries, the ROI is smaller but still significant for career flexibility.
Time is money
For Indians, employer-sponsored EB-2 means 10-15 years of career restrictions. EB-1A means freedom in 2-3 years.
Career flexibility has enormous value
Green card holders can switch jobs, start companies, negotiate without fear, and invest without restrictions.
The $20K investment pays back quickly
Higher salaries from negotiating without visa dependency, starting companies, or changing jobs often exceed $20K within 1-2 years.
For non-backlog countries, ROI is different
No time savings, but independence from employer + ability to self-petition has value.
Risk assessment matters
If you're not confident in EB-1A approval, the $20K could be lost to denial.
Employer-sponsored green card isn't "free"
You pay with years of career limitations, lower negotiating power, and job insecurity.
Time is money
For Indians, employer-sponsored EB-2 means 10-15 years of career restrictions. EB-1A means freedom in 2-3 years.
Career flexibility has enormous value
Green card holders can switch jobs, start companies, negotiate without fear, and invest without restrictions.
The $20K investment pays back quickly
Higher salaries from negotiating without visa dependency, starting companies, or changing jobs often exceed $20K within 1-2 years.
For non-backlog countries, ROI is different
No time savings, but independence from employer + ability to self-petition has value.
Risk assessment matters
If you're not confident in EB-1A approval, the $20K could be lost to denial.
Employer-sponsored green card isn't "free"
You pay with years of career limitations, lower negotiating power, and job insecurity.
What employer sponsorship "costs" you:
1. Time (Most Significant)
India EB-2: 10-15+ years waiting
China EB-2: 2-5 years waiting
Most countries: 1-3 years waiting
2. Career Flexibility
Must stay with employer (or risk losing place in line)
Limited negotiating power (employer knows you're visa-dependent)
Can't easily switch to higher-paying opportunities
Can't start your own company
3. Job Security Risk
If laid off, must find new sponsor within 60 days
Priority date can be lost if I-140 not approved for 180 days
Employer controls your immigration status
4. Salary Suppression
Studies show H-1B workers earn 10-15% less than comparable citizens
You can't negotiate aggressively when employer controls visa
"Golden handcuffs" keep you in suboptimal roles
5. Life Planning Uncertainty
Can't commit to buying house (might be forced to leave)
Hesitant to have children (unclear long-term status)
Parents can't visit easily (dependent on your visa stability)
Scenario: Indian software engineer, 30 years old, $200K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0 (employer pays most fees)
Timeline: ~15 years to green card
Green card at age: 45
Years of restricted career: 15
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000 (self-paid)
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Green card at age: 32-33
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Value of 12+ Years of Career Freedom:
1. Salary Negotiation Power
With green card, can negotiate 10-15% higher salary
$200K × 10% = $20K/year additional
Over 12 years: $240K additional earnings
2. Job Mobility
Can switch to higher-paying opportunities
Estimated value: $50K-$200K in career advancement
3. Entrepreneurship Optionality
Can start company without visa complications
Value: Potentially unlimited
4. Reduced Stress/Life Planning
Can buy house, plan family, bring parents
Value: Priceless (but real)
Total Estimated Value: $300K-$500K+ over 12 years
ROI: Invest $25K, gain $300K+ = 12-20x return
Scenario: Chinese researcher, 35 years old, $180K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0
Timeline: ~5 years to green card
Green card at age: 40
Years of restricted career: 5
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Green card at age: 37-38
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Value of 2-3 Years of Career Freedom:
1. Salary Negotiation
10% higher salary for 2-3 years
$180K × 10% × 2.5 years = $45K
2. Job Mobility
2-3 years earlier freedom to change jobs
Value: Variable but real
3. Reduced Risk
Not dependent on employer for 2-3 additional years
Value: Risk mitigation
Total Estimated Value: $50K-$100K over 2-3 years
ROI: Invest $25K, gain $50K-$100K = 2-4x return
Scenario: Brazilian engineer, 32 years old, $170K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Time savings: Minimal (no backlog for either path)
Value is different:
Independence from employer during process
No need to stay at current job for sponsorship
Can change jobs immediately without affecting case
Survives layoffs (employer doesn't control your green card)
ROI calculation:
If employer sponsorship works smoothly: ROI is lower (mainly independence value)
If you want to change jobs or start company: ROI is high (enables career moves)
If you get laid off during process: ROI is extremely high (saves your green card)
Conclusion for non-backlog countries: ROI depends on your specific situation. If career flexibility is valuable to you, self-petition is worth it. If you're happy staying at current employer, employer sponsorship may be sufficient.
The risk: You spend $25K on EB-1A and it's denied.
How to assess risk:
High Approval Likelihood (60-80%):
You clearly meet 4+ criteria
Evidence is strong and well-documented
Attorney is experienced with EB-1A
Similar profiles have been approved
Moderate Approval Likelihood (40-60%):
You meet 3 criteria but evidence is moderate
Some criteria are borderline
Case has some weaknesses
Low Approval Likelihood (<40%):
You barely meet 3 criteria
Evidence is weak or poorly documented
Significant gaps in your profile
Risk-adjusted ROI calculation:
For Indian with 70% approval likelihood:
Expected value = 70% × $300K (if approved) + 30% × (-$25K) (if denied)
Expected value = $210K - $7.5K = $202.5K
ROI still strongly positive
Decision framework:
If approval likelihood > 50% AND you're from backlog country: Almost always worth it
If approval likelihood > 70% AND you're from any country: Likely worth it
If approval likelihood < 40%: Build more evidence before filing
Employer sponsorship isn't actually free. You pay with:
1. Opportunity Cost
Jobs you don't apply for because they won't sponsor
Startups you can't join
Companies that would pay more but have different visa policies
2. Negotiation Weakness
Lower salary because you can't credibly threaten to leave
Slower promotions because employer knows you're stuck
Less equity because you're perceived as having fewer options
3. Career Path Limitations
Can't pivot to entrepreneurship
Can't take career breaks
Can't pursue risky opportunities
4. Mental Health Impact
Constant anxiety about visa status
Stress during layoffs
Feeling trapped in suboptimal situations
Estimated hidden cost: $20K-$100K/year in foregone opportunities and suppressed earnings.
1. You Don't Qualify (Yet)
If you don't meet 3 criteria, don't file
Build evidence first, then file when ready
2. You're From Non-Backlog Country and Happy at Employer
If employer will sponsor EB-2 and you want to stay there
Minimal time difference doesn't justify $25K
3. Employer Will Pay for Self-Petition
Some employers pay for EB-1A as retention tool
If employer pays, no out-of-pocket cost for you
4. You Can't Afford the Risk
If $25K loss would be devastating
Wait until you have financial cushion
Best of both worlds:
1. File EB-1A (self-petition):
Pay $25K
Timeline: 2-3 years if approved
No backlog for any country
2. Simultaneously maintain employer-sponsored EB-2:
Employer files PERM/I-140
Your priority date is locked in
Backup if EB-1A is denied
Why this works:
If EB-1A is approved: Use it, get green card in 2-3 years
If EB-1A is denied: Fall back to employer-sponsored path with priority date you've been building
Cost: $25K extra for EB-1A + lost if denied
Benefit: Maximum optionality, fastest path if you qualify
Time Savings Calculator
Input your country of birth, current status, and salary. OpenSphere calculates years saved via self-petition vs employer sponsorship.
Financial Value Estimate
Based on salary, industry, and career goals, OpenSphere estimates the value of career freedom (negotiating power, job mobility, entrepreneurship).
Risk Assessment
OpenSphere evaluates your evidence strength and provides approval probability estimate for risk-adjusted ROI.
Decision Recommendation
Based on your specific numbers, OpenSphere recommends:
Self-petition now (clear ROI),
Build more evidence (approval risk too high),
Consider both paths (parallel filing strategy).
Factor | Employer-Sponsored | Self-Petition (EB-1A) |
Out-of-pocket cost | Low ($2K-$5K for I-485) | High ($20K-$30K) |
Timeline (India) | 10-15+ years | 2-3 years |
Timeline (China) | 2-5 years | 2-3 years |
Timeline (others) | 1-3 years | 2-3 years |
Employer dependency | High (must stay for sponsorship) | None |
Survives layoff | Partially (if I-140 approved 180+ days) | Fully |
Career flexibility | Limited during process | Full upon approval |
ROI for Indians | "Free" but costs 10+ years | 12-20x return |
ROI for Chinese | "Free" but costs 2-3 extra years | 2-4x return |
ROI for others | Minimal time difference | Primarily flexibility value |
Want to calculate your personal ROI for self-petition vs employer sponsorship, including time savings, financial value, and approval probability?
Take the OpenSphere evaluation. You'll get personalized ROI analysis for your specific situation.
Calculate Your Immigration ROI
What employer sponsorship "costs" you:
1. Time (Most Significant)
India EB-2: 10-15+ years waiting
China EB-2: 2-5 years waiting
Most countries: 1-3 years waiting
2. Career Flexibility
Must stay with employer (or risk losing place in line)
Limited negotiating power (employer knows you're visa-dependent)
Can't easily switch to higher-paying opportunities
Can't start your own company
3. Job Security Risk
If laid off, must find new sponsor within 60 days
Priority date can be lost if I-140 not approved for 180 days
Employer controls your immigration status
4. Salary Suppression
Studies show H-1B workers earn 10-15% less than comparable citizens
You can't negotiate aggressively when employer controls visa
"Golden handcuffs" keep you in suboptimal roles
5. Life Planning Uncertainty
Can't commit to buying house (might be forced to leave)
Hesitant to have children (unclear long-term status)
Parents can't visit easily (dependent on your visa stability)
Scenario: Indian software engineer, 30 years old, $200K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0 (employer pays most fees)
Timeline: ~15 years to green card
Green card at age: 45
Years of restricted career: 15
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000 (self-paid)
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Green card at age: 32-33
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Value of 12+ Years of Career Freedom:
1. Salary Negotiation Power
With green card, can negotiate 10-15% higher salary
$200K × 10% = $20K/year additional
Over 12 years: $240K additional earnings
2. Job Mobility
Can switch to higher-paying opportunities
Estimated value: $50K-$200K in career advancement
3. Entrepreneurship Optionality
Can start company without visa complications
Value: Potentially unlimited
4. Reduced Stress/Life Planning
Can buy house, plan family, bring parents
Value: Priceless (but real)
Total Estimated Value: $300K-$500K+ over 12 years
ROI: Invest $25K, gain $300K+ = 12-20x return
Scenario: Chinese researcher, 35 years old, $180K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0
Timeline: ~5 years to green card
Green card at age: 40
Years of restricted career: 5
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Green card at age: 37-38
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Value of 2-3 Years of Career Freedom:
1. Salary Negotiation
10% higher salary for 2-3 years
$180K × 10% × 2.5 years = $45K
2. Job Mobility
2-3 years earlier freedom to change jobs
Value: Variable but real
3. Reduced Risk
Not dependent on employer for 2-3 additional years
Value: Risk mitigation
Total Estimated Value: $50K-$100K over 2-3 years
ROI: Invest $25K, gain $50K-$100K = 2-4x return
Scenario: Brazilian engineer, 32 years old, $170K salary
Option A: Employer-Sponsored EB-2
Cost: $0
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Option B: Self-Petitioned EB-1A
Cost: $25,000
Timeline: ~2-3 years to green card
Years of restricted career: 2-3
Time savings: Minimal (no backlog for either path)
Value is different:
Independence from employer during process
No need to stay at current job for sponsorship
Can change jobs immediately without affecting case
Survives layoffs (employer doesn't control your green card)
ROI calculation:
If employer sponsorship works smoothly: ROI is lower (mainly independence value)
If you want to change jobs or start company: ROI is high (enables career moves)
If you get laid off during process: ROI is extremely high (saves your green card)
Conclusion for non-backlog countries: ROI depends on your specific situation. If career flexibility is valuable to you, self-petition is worth it. If you're happy staying at current employer, employer sponsorship may be sufficient.
The risk: You spend $25K on EB-1A and it's denied.
How to assess risk:
High Approval Likelihood (60-80%):
You clearly meet 4+ criteria
Evidence is strong and well-documented
Attorney is experienced with EB-1A
Similar profiles have been approved
Moderate Approval Likelihood (40-60%):
You meet 3 criteria but evidence is moderate
Some criteria are borderline
Case has some weaknesses
Low Approval Likelihood (<40%):
You barely meet 3 criteria
Evidence is weak or poorly documented
Significant gaps in your profile
Risk-adjusted ROI calculation:
For Indian with 70% approval likelihood:
Expected value = 70% × $300K (if approved) + 30% × (-$25K) (if denied)
Expected value = $210K - $7.5K = $202.5K
ROI still strongly positive
Decision framework:
If approval likelihood > 50% AND you're from backlog country: Almost always worth it
If approval likelihood > 70% AND you're from any country: Likely worth it
If approval likelihood < 40%: Build more evidence before filing
Employer sponsorship isn't actually free. You pay with:
1. Opportunity Cost
Jobs you don't apply for because they won't sponsor
Startups you can't join
Companies that would pay more but have different visa policies
2. Negotiation Weakness
Lower salary because you can't credibly threaten to leave
Slower promotions because employer knows you're stuck
Less equity because you're perceived as having fewer options
3. Career Path Limitations
Can't pivot to entrepreneurship
Can't take career breaks
Can't pursue risky opportunities
4. Mental Health Impact
Constant anxiety about visa status
Stress during layoffs
Feeling trapped in suboptimal situations
Estimated hidden cost: $20K-$100K/year in foregone opportunities and suppressed earnings.
1. You Don't Qualify (Yet)
If you don't meet 3 criteria, don't file
Build evidence first, then file when ready
2. You're From Non-Backlog Country and Happy at Employer
If employer will sponsor EB-2 and you want to stay there
Minimal time difference doesn't justify $25K
3. Employer Will Pay for Self-Petition
Some employers pay for EB-1A as retention tool
If employer pays, no out-of-pocket cost for you
4. You Can't Afford the Risk
If $25K loss would be devastating
Wait until you have financial cushion
Best of both worlds:
1. File EB-1A (self-petition):
Pay $25K
Timeline: 2-3 years if approved
No backlog for any country
2. Simultaneously maintain employer-sponsored EB-2:
Employer files PERM/I-140
Your priority date is locked in
Backup if EB-1A is denied
Why this works:
If EB-1A is approved: Use it, get green card in 2-3 years
If EB-1A is denied: Fall back to employer-sponsored path with priority date you've been building
Cost: $25K extra for EB-1A + lost if denied
Benefit: Maximum optionality, fastest path if you qualify
Time Savings Calculator
Input your country of birth, current status, and salary. OpenSphere calculates years saved via self-petition vs employer sponsorship.
Financial Value Estimate
Based on salary, industry, and career goals, OpenSphere estimates the value of career freedom (negotiating power, job mobility, entrepreneurship).
Risk Assessment
OpenSphere evaluates your evidence strength and provides approval probability estimate for risk-adjusted ROI.
Decision Recommendation
Based on your specific numbers, OpenSphere recommends:
Self-petition now (clear ROI),
Build more evidence (approval risk too high),
Consider both paths (parallel filing strategy).
Factor | Employer-Sponsored | Self-Petition (EB-1A) |
Out-of-pocket cost | Low ($2K-$5K for I-485) | High ($20K-$30K) |
Timeline (India) | 10-15+ years | 2-3 years |
Timeline (China) | 2-5 years | 2-3 years |
Timeline (others) | 1-3 years | 2-3 years |
Employer dependency | High (must stay for sponsorship) | None |
Survives layoff | Partially (if I-140 approved 180+ days) | Fully |
Career flexibility | Limited during process | Full upon approval |
ROI for Indians | "Free" but costs 10+ years | 12-20x return |
ROI for Chinese | "Free" but costs 2-3 extra years | 2-4x return |
ROI for others | Minimal time difference | Primarily flexibility value |
Want to calculate your personal ROI for self-petition vs employer sponsorship, including time savings, financial value, and approval probability?
Take the OpenSphere evaluation. You'll get personalized ROI analysis for your specific situation.
Calculate Your Immigration ROI
1. Is $20K-$30K typical for EB-1A?
Yes. Attorney fees ($10K-$20K), USCIS fees ($2K), evidence preparation ($3K-$8K), and medical exam ($500) add up.
2. Can I get employer to pay for EB-1A?
Some employers will, especially in competitive hiring. Worth asking.
3. What if I file EB-1A and it's denied?
You lose the filing costs but can refile when evidence is stronger. Employer-sponsored path continues unaffected.
4. Is EB-2 NIW cheaper than EB-1A?
Slightly ($15K-$25K typical), but NIW has backlog for Indians. EB-1A has no backlog.
5. Can I file EB-1A while on H-1B?
Yes. Many maintain H-1B while self-petition processes.
6. How do I know if I qualify for EB-1A?
Get an evaluation. Many underestimate their qualifications.
7. What's the approval rate for EB-1A?
Well-prepared cases: 60-80%. Poorly prepared: 20-30%. Quality of evidence and presentation matters enormously.
8. Can I deduct immigration costs from taxes?
Generally no for personal immigration. Consult a tax professional.
9. Should I file EB-1A or NIW first?
If you clearly qualify for EB-1A, file EB-1A (no backlog). If EB-1A is risky, NIW may be safer (lower bar).
10. What if my employer sponsored EB-2 and I want to switch to EB-1A?
You can do both simultaneously. Keep employer-sponsored as backup while filing self-petition.
Explore Topics
0%
Explore Topics
0%
